Hungarian Yearbook of International Law and European Law 2016

Contributors xi
Editor’s Note xv

Part I Thematic Part: Protection of Cultural Property

1 Universality, ProgressiveRealization, EconomicCrises –The ICESR Fifty Years on 3
Gábor Kardos
2 Cultural Rights as a Tool of Protecting the Rights of Indigenous Peoples 15
György Marinkás
3 Lessons of Sevso Case – Restitution Challenges of the Illegally Exported Cultural Property 39
Vanda Vadász
4 Hungary’s Place and Role in the International Legal Protection of Cultural Heritage – ‘Les longs souvenirs font les grands peuples’ 59
Mária Mihály and Henrietta Galambos
5 Change Offers Swiss Cultural Property Protection a Window of Opportunity 91
Rino Büchel

Part II Forum: The Cafeteria Case

6 NationalInterestsin theCommon Market – SZÉPCard and Erzsébet Voucher before the European Court of Justice 101
Ernő Várnay
7 The Hungarian Cold Food Voucher Case – A Somewhat Rigorous Approach of the Court on the Interpretation of Free Movement Provisions 115
Réka Somssich



Part III Developments in International Law

8 Terrorism and Rule of Law 127
Péter Darák
9 General Principles of Law in the Practice of International Courts and the European Court of Justice 135
Marcel Szabó
10 TheConcept of GlobalConstitutionalism as aRoad-Trip to Freedom for Local Democracies in Transition Times 155
Ielyzaveta Lvova
11 Transforming Our World – New Agenda and Goals for Sustainable Development 167
Zsuzsanna Horváth
12 Preliminary Legal Issues in the Historic Paris Climate Agreement 195
András Huszár
13 The ‘Hidden’ Definition of Water Pollution in the UNECE Water Convention 203
Ágnes Bujdos
14 In Fairnessto Future Generations –Building Effective Public Participation 231
Sándor Fülöp
15 The Aarhus Convention Model 251
Attila Pánovics
16 Article 27 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights – The Wording and Its Implications 263
György Andrássy
17 Private Messages at Work – Strasbourg Court of Human Right’s Judgement in Bărbulescu v. Romania Case 293
Veronika Szeghalmi

18 The Question of Prison Overcrowding as Reflected in the Decisions of the European Court of Human Rights 299
Zoltán Tallódi
19 Liability for Third-Party Comments before the European Court of Human Rights – Comparing the Estonian Delfi and the Hungarian Index-MTE Decisions 315
János Tamás Papp
20 The Concept of the European Political Party 327
Péter Smuk
21 Did Not Lose Their Public Asset Quality 347
Lilla Berkes
22 Three Models of Minority Media Participation – A Brief Analysis of Language Related Prescriptions in National Media Laws 353
Petra Lea Láncos
23 International RedCross and RedCrescent Movement and Humanitarian Activities for Migrants 369
Réka Varga

Part IV Developments in European Law

24 ConstitutionalIdentity asInterpreted by theCouncil of Europe and the European Union – Conflict of Laws – Conflict of Courts? 385
András Zs. Varga
25 Parliament versusConstitutionalCourt – Selected Issues Pertaining to the Constitutional Dispute in Poland 407
Marcin Stębelski
26 The Limits of Member State Solidarity – The Legal Analysis of the Dano and the Alimanovic Cases 431
Laura Gyeney
27 The External Side of Parliamentary Democracy – Comment on the Case C-658/11 European Parliament v. Council of the European Union 449
Ildikó Bartha

28 The European Leniency Programme and the EuropeanCartel Settlement Procedure – General Overview and Selected Issues 475
Botond Horváth
29 The Szekler National Council’s European Citizens’ Initiative – for the Equality of the Regions and Sustainability of the Regional Cultures at the Court of Justice of the European Union 489
Balázs Tárnok
30 The Human Rights Aspect of the Common Commercial Policy in the History of the Integration of the European Union 507
András Kásler

Part V Proceedings of the FIDE XXVII Doctoral Congress in Budapest

31 The XXVIIth Congress ofthe International Federation for European Law (FIDE) – Budapest, 18-21 May 2016 527
Kinga Debisso
32 Political and Legal Accountability in the European Banking Union – A First Assessment 535
Menelaos Markakis
33 Challenges Related to the Power of the European Central Bank to Apply National Law 559
Olivier Voordeckers
34 An Overview of Litigation in the Context of Financial Assistance to Eurozone Member States 573
Anastasia Karatzia
35 TheCJEU and the Interpretative Principles as Vehiclesfor Development of Damages Actions in EU (Competition) Law – Any Room for Overcompensation? 591
Petra Weingerl

36 Piecemeal Harmonization of European Civil Law – The Case of Limitation Periods in the Antitrust Damages Directive 613
Miriam Buiten
37 The Limitations of the Common Commercial Policy as an Exclusive Competence of the European Union 637
Plarent Ruka

Part VI Hungarian State Practice

38 The Ungváry Case before the Hungarian Courts and the European Court of Human Rights 651
András Koltay
39 Restrictions on the Freedom of Assembly – Seeking the Domestic and International Legal Practice on theConflict betweenRights and Freedoms of “Them” and “Others” 669
Barnabás Hajas and Réka Török
40 The Role of the Constitutional Protection of Social Rights in the Framework of the Changing Labour Market 685
Henriett Rab
41 Equal Employment in Hungarian Labour Law – Effective Principle or Uncertain Framework 697
Márton Leó Zaccaria
42 Dispute on the ‘Tokaj’ – But Whose Property is the ‘Tokaji’? 715
Krisztina Bíró

Part VII Review of Hungarian Scholarly Literature

43 Review of the Monograph on ‘Information – Society – Security’ – Zsolt Haig: Információ – társadalom – biztonság 741
Árpád Varga

44 Varju-Várnay (Editors),The Lawofthe European Union in Hungary (HVG-ORAC, 2014) 745
Attila Vincze
45 Religions, the State and Freedom of Speech 749
Levente Nyakas